Effectiveness of Hunting in Survival Situation

We all have seen survivalists on television hunting down a deer, wild boar or squirrel with a spear. It is an entertaining idea but how realistic is it?


Collecting protein in the wild is vital for survival. It stops the degradation of your body due to starvation and allows for mental focus and physical strength. However, hunting can be physically risky and can expend thousands of calories.


The question we will pose in this article is to argue the validity of actively hunting for food in a survival scenario.


Options for Getting Food


Much of this debate consists of comparing hunting to other methods to obtain food. There are four primary options for gathering food in a survival situation.

  1. You can collect wild edibles but they do not provide much protein. However, collecting them requires very few calories and is almost a guaranteed meal.
  2. You can go fishing but that requires a rod and reel. You can fashion fishing gear from natural materials but it is tough.
  3. You can set a series of traps. Trapping allows you to work on other projects after the traps are set but success of having a catch is unpredictable.
  4. You can consider regular hunting, but for this you would need a rifle or a good hunting bow. There is another option though, primitive hunting. It is very challenging and requires lots of patience and effort but it can result in huge amounts of protein.


What Primitive Hunting Requires?


1. Weapon


To be successful with hunting, you must have the right weapons and be skillful in using them. This is the biggest challenge with primitive hunting.


Your prey is usually very fast and its senses are stronger than yours. Your defense must allow you to hit your prey at a distance and deliver a killing or disabling blow. There are several options that you can consider for this endeavor.


Throwing Stick


The simplest option for a weapon is a throwing stick. It’s a stick about 2 to 3 feet long, preferably with a large knot on one end. A good throwing stick can be landed accurately at about 30 to 40 yards.


With an end heavy design, it is thrown overhand and rotates as it approaches its target. It often disables prey without killing it. You must be prepared to rush in and deliver a killing blow in this case.




Spears are ideal for close quarter strikes but can also be thrown if needed.


If you are hunting a large animal, a single point is most useful to penetrate the vital organs. If you are shooting a smaller animal, then a four point spear is better to ensure that a point lands.


To make a four point spear, you need to split the point into four separate points and then shove small sticks into the gaps to spread out the points.


Either style of spear needs to be hardened in a fire to ensure the points penetrate. If you plan to throw the spear, you may want to add fletching at its end to help it fly true.


Spears are ideal for small game like frogs and fish or larger game such as wild hogs.




The atlatl is the next step in weapon evolution. It is a thin throwing spear with a new throwing arm to increase velocity and distance. These spears typically have to fletch, and the throwing arm has a notch on the end to hook to the end of the spear.


The additional distance that the throwing arm provides gives the same leverage you would get from having a longer arm. This allows accurate throws of up to 100 yards. It is best used for large game, but with practice can work on a smaller game as well.


Bow & Arrow


The final step in primitive weapon evolution is the bow and arrow. It takes spring energy and transfers it from a string to an arrow. It can be fired with more accuracy than any other primitive weapon but is also the most difficult to build.


The right type of wood must be used to ensure that the bow retains its spring without breaking. Locust or Osage orange trees are ideal for making bows. Once the bow is carved to shape, the string must be added. Then arrows must be crafted with fletching at one end and an arrowhead on the other.


Arrowheads can be fabricated from stone, glass, or metal. This allows the arrow to do significant damage to the prey when it strikes.


2. Stalking



One of the most forgotten aspect of hunting is the art of stalking prey. Because of high-powered rifles with scopes, most hunters no longer need to stalk their prey.


However, when hunting in a primitive nature, you must get closer without being noticed. This means tracking first their activity. You must be able to identify both tracks and scat to know where the animals are traveling. Game trails are another significant clue.


As you approach the prey, you must be able to remain hidden and silent. Camouflage’s hard in a survival situation. Usually, your best option is to cover yourself in mud and tuck small leafy branches into your clothing wherever possible.


You can cover your scent by rubbing ash from your fire on your body or using other natural scents such as pine or spruce needles. To feel twigs and leaves under your feet, you should hunt barefoot so you can stay silent.

Calories Spent


When hunting, you typically are very active. Sure there are types of hunting where you sit on a tree stand all day, but that is not primitive hunting.


To collect your meal, you must walk the woods all day until you find you prey. This requires you to expend thousands of calories. You are also risking injury as you might trip and fall, twist an ankle, or get bitten by a snake.


Then, if you do kill an animal, you must use more calories gutting and cleaning it for preparation.


3. Using All the Meat


One of the largest challenges of primitive hunting is ensuring that you get to benefit from all of the meat.


If you kill a wild hog and do not have a method by which to preserve the meat, you have only provided yourself with one meal.


To ensure that you avoid this problem, you should be skilled in drying meat before you are faced with a survival scenario. With these tactics, you can save your meat for weeks without it spoiling.


Will I Get Anything?


This is the big question when it comes to hunting. The odds are definitely against you.


If you decide to hunt with primitive weapons, it is very likely that you will be coming home empty handed. The chances of finding prey within firing range and hitting that prey are small — meaning, you may come back without any food.


There are two primary problems with this:

  1. You have expended a significant amount of calories without consuming any calories.
  2. You are creating frustration that you did not have previously. Morale is a huge deal when it comes to survival.


Concluding Thoughts

In this discussion of primitive hunting versus other types of food procurement, I have to say that active hunting is a bad idea in most cases given these reasons:

  • You risk a great deal when you go out hunting.
  • You consume calories building weapons and you use up more as you hunt.
  • You risk your safety as you walk through the wilderness.
  • You face the odds of likely not coming home with any food.


I feel that there are better ways to get food. Sure it is nice to think that you can take a walk in the woods and come back with meat for days, but it just does not work that way.


Survival is not a television show. There are situations where hunting might make sense but typically, there are better ways to find food. I have been in several survival situations and have only been able to successfully hunt for food in a few of those circumstances.


What matters most is that you analyze the situation. If you have easy prey and an effective weapon, you might have a chance. When it comes right down to it, you must find food one way or the other.


If hunting is your option, then go with it. If not, go another route. Either way, finding protein is essential. When the time comes that you must rely on these methods for finding food, consider your choice and select what makes the most sense.

3 Replies to “Effectiveness of Hunting in Survival Situation

  1. Aw, this was a actually good publish. In principle I want to set in producing like this furthermore – taking time and actual work to make an excellent article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and not at all seem to get some thing accomplished.

  2. In the awesome pattern of things you actually get a B+ just for effort. Exactly where you lost me ended up being on your facts. As they say, the devil is in the details… And it couldn’t be more true at this point. Having said that, allow me say to you just what exactly did work. Your article (parts of it) is definitely incredibly powerful which is most likely the reason why I am taking an effort to comment. I do not really make it a regular habit of doing that. Secondly, despite the fact that I can easily notice a leaps in reasoning you come up with, I am not convinced of just how you appear to connect your ideas which in turn make the conclusion. For now I will, no doubt subscribe to your issue however wish in the near future you actually connect the dots better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *